Formation,
not just information.

A guided journey through the Great Books and Holy Scripture, one lesson at a time. Reclaim your attention and feed your soul.

BonitasVeritasPulchritudo

pai·dei·a

/ pī-ˈdā-ə /n. · Greek παιδεία

The complete training of a person: the shaping of mind, morals, and body toward virtue.

live

/ līv /adj.

Experienced in real time; unfolding in the moment.

The Practice

Every lesson, in the company of the greatest minds.

One classic text and one sacred text, with the background you need to read them and a commentary on why they belong together.

01

Background

Contextual information about the lesson's readings: who is writing, when, and why it matters.

02

Two Readings

A classic text and a sacred text that have something to say together, paired by theme rather than chance. Every classic appears in a fresh Paideia translation, made for the modern reader.

03

Commentary

Exposition and juxtaposition of the texts: what each one argues, and what emerges when they meet.

04

Reflection

Questions to promote reflection about the reading, worth carrying into the rest of your day.

Optional

Paideia Editions

The Great Books, translated anew.

Every classic work in the curriculum is provided in the Paideia Edition: a complete, fresh rendering that respects the original author's context and intent while presenting the ideas in clear, contemporary English. Each is also available in multiple lengths, so you decide how much time to invest in any given lesson. See the following examples from the opening of Dante's Inferno.

The Longfellow Edition

Midway upon the journey of our life I found myself within a forest dark, for the straightforward pathway had been lost. Ah me! how hard a thing it is to say what was this forest savage, rough, and stern, which in the very thought renews the fear. So bitter is it, death is little more; but of the good to treat, which there I found, speak will I of the other things I saw there.

The Paideia Edition

Full

8 min

The complete text

Midway through life's journey, I came to myself within a dark forest—the straight path had vanished. How arduous it is to describe that forest: savage, tangled, bitter. The mere memory renews the dread. Death itself is scarcely more harrowing. To speak of the good I discovered there, I must first tell of all else I witnessed.

Brief

3 min

Condensed, in the author's voice

Midway through life's journey, I came to myself inside a dark forest where the straight path had vanished. The memory alone renews my dread.

Summary

1 min

The argument, in plain prose

Halfway through life, Dante finds himself lost in a dark forest, having strayed from the true path.

The Curriculum

The Great Conversation

Four movements. 365 lessons. One argument.

Quarter I

The Examined Life

Virtue, wisdom, and the soul's order through ancient philosophy and Scripture.

  • Lessons 1–30

    Plato · Genesis, Psalms

  • Lessons 31–61

    Aristotle, Epictetus, Aurelius · Proverbs, Job

  • Lessons 62–91

    Seneca, Cicero · Ecclesiastes, James

Quarter II

The Restless Heart

Sin, grace, and the pilgrim city through confession, consolation, and medieval verse.

  • Lessons 92–121

    Augustine · Romans, John, Hebrews

  • Lessons 122–152

    Boethius, Dante · Isaiah, Song of Solomon

  • Lessons 153–182

    Luther · Luke, Galatians

Quarter III

Faith and Freedom

The reformation of mind and nation through Enlightenment philosophy and American political thought.

  • Lessons 183–212

    Pascal, Locke, Burke, Paine · Exodus, 1 Kings, Jeremiah

  • Lessons 213–243

    Lincoln, Douglass, Tocqueville, Rousseau · Deuteronomy, Judges

  • Lessons 244–273

    MacDonald, Tocqueville, Chesterton, Tolstoy · Mark, Hosea, Micah

Quarter IV

Crisis and Hope

Modernity's challenge and Christianity's answer through modern philosophy, the novel, and apologetics.

  • Lessons 274–304

    Nietzsche · 1-2 Corinthians, Colossians, Lamentations

  • Lessons 305–335

    Dostoevsky · Matthew, 1 John

  • Lessons 336–365

    Chesterton, MacDonald · Acts, 1-2 Peter, Revelation

Lesson One, Free

Better experienced than explained.

Want to experience the journey? The entire first lesson awaits below, with no account or subscription required.

Today's Lesson

Your reading and reflection.

01. Introduction

Introduction

Context for the readings

Before anyone asked whether a human being ought to be good, there was the question of what a human being was made for. The ancient Babylonians had an answer. In the Enuma Elish, a poem recited at Babylon's New Year festival, the god Marduk kills the sea goddess Tiamat and makes the world from her divided body. Human beings are made from the blood of another defeated god, Qingu, so that they can take up the gods' labour and the gods can rest. Genesis begins with the same great subjects—heaven and earth, the waters, the making of man—but belongs to Israel, whose account of beginnings concerns the whole human race before there was an Israel. Abram does not appear until the end of the eleventh chapter. Jewish and Christian tradition attributes Genesis and the other four books of the Law to Moses, who led Israel out of Egypt and received the law at Sinai; Genesis itself does not name its author. Most critical scholars place the book's final form during or after the Babylonian exile, when Judeans lived among the heirs of the civilization that told the Enuma Elish. Both stories say what place a human being occupies in a world he did not make. Genesis gives its account of the beginning twice. The first tells of creation on the scale of heaven and earth; the second begins again, closer to the ground, with dust, a garden, and the God it calls Yahweh.

Continue Reading

Plato wrote the Republic after watching his city discover how little its laws could protect it from its rulers. Born around 428 BC, he grew up during Athens's long war with Sparta, which ended in defeat in 404. The victorious Spartans backed a government of thirty Athenian oligarchs, led by Plato's relative Critias, who seized property and executed citizens and resident foreigners. The restored democracy then tried Socrates, Plato's teacher, for impiety and corrupting the young, and put him to death in 399. Plato had seen tyranny and democracy kill men in the name of the city. His Republic, written probably in the 370s, asks whether justice is something more than what those with power choose to call it. Plato never speaks in the dialogue; Socrates tells the story in the first person, recalling an evening in the Piraeus, Athens's harbour town, at the house of Cephalus, a wealthy resident foreigner who ran a shield-making business. The household has a history beyond the conversation. In 404 the Thirty confiscated the family's property and executed Cephalus's son Polemarchus without trial. Plato gives that same Polemarchus a prominent part in the discussion of justice. The dialogue never tells us what became of him, but its first readers knew.

02. Readings

Genesis 1-2

Sacred Text · 8 mins

God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them.

Length
Format

Plato

Republic Book I, 327a–336a · 16 mins

Then harming anyone, friend or enemy, isn't the act of a just person. It's the act of the unjust.

Length
Format
03. Commentary

Commentary

Reflection on the readings

What makes a human being worth something? We are accustomed to answering with the things people do: their courage, their kindness, their intelligence, the work they accomplish, the good they bring into other people's lives. We admire excellence and despise its opposite. Yet we hesitate before the consequence. If a person's worth comes from what he does, what becomes of the man who does nothing well, or who has done something terrible? We may rightly judge him wicked, but we are reluctant to say that he has thereby become worthless. Something in our judgment of human beings seems to survive our judgment of their conduct. The distinction is familiar enough in life, but difficult to explain. It lies near the heart of both books with which this curriculum begins.

Continue Reading

Genesis gives human beings their standing before they have done anything at all. The first man has not demonstrated courage, wisdom, or justice. He has not even made a choice. Yet God creates him in his image, blesses him, and gives him dominion over the living world. The ancient language of the image makes the gift more startling. The Hebrew word is tselem ("image, representation"), the word for a figure that could stand in a temple for the god it represented, and in the kingdoms around Israel a king could be called the image of his god, his representative on earth. Genesis gives that distinction to man, male and female alike. The dignity of kingship is bestowed on people who have no kingdom, no subjects, and no achievements to their names. Nor is the gift presented as a reward for goodness. God sees that what he has made is good before its creatures have had the opportunity to prove themselves good or bad. The question of what a human being deserves comes after the question of what a human being is.

Plato begins elsewhere. Socrates does not appeal to a creator or to a dignity bestowed at birth. He asks what makes something good as the kind of thing it is. A horse can be injured in a way that makes it worse as a horse, and a human being can be made worse in the excellence proper to human beings. The word is arete ("excellence"), the same for a horse and a man, and it is what lets the argument pass from the stable to the city. Polemarchus agrees that justice is human excellence. If harming a person makes him less just, Socrates reasons, then a just man cannot make another person unjust through justice, even when that person is his enemy. The argument has a peculiar force. Socrates does not ask us to pity the enemy, forgive his offenses, or pretend that he is good. He asks whether making another person worse can possibly be the work of justice. Yet the proof rests on an agreement the men have not examined: that justice is the excellence proper to human beings. They have reached a conclusion about how one person ought to treat another without establishing what a human being is for.

The two accounts become interesting where they cease to coincide. Genesis gives human beings a standing that precedes their conduct. Socrates considers an excellence that injury can diminish. These are not necessarily rival accounts, but neither is one simply the explanation of the other. A wicked man may have lost much of the excellence Socrates describes without ceasing to bear the image Genesis declares. Yet that image does not by itself tell us what justice requires when the wicked man threatens someone else. Socrates' argument leaves a difficulty of its own. A man may be robbed, imprisoned, or beaten without becoming less just; suffering an injustice may even reveal an excellence that would otherwise have remained hidden. If harm means the diminishment of human excellence, what distinguishes it from the injuries we ordinarily call harm? Genesis gives us reason to distinguish a person's worth from his virtue; Plato makes us ask what virtue is, and what can truly damage it. Neither question can be settled simply by answering the other.

The most consequential difference, however, concerns where the measure comes from. In Genesis, God sees that what he has made is good. The judgment belongs to the maker, and human beings receive their place in an order they did not establish. In the Republic, Socrates and his companions must discover the measure by which human conduct can be judged. They begin with inherited sayings, test them against examples, and find that even the most respectable definitions cannot survive examination. The first book ends without a satisfactory account of justice. Genesis begins with a declaration that does not wait for examination. These are not merely different literary forms. They place human beings in different relations to the truth they seek: in one, they must learn to understand what has been given; in the other, they must submit what they believe to the discipline of questioning.

Here begins the conversation between Athens and Jerusalem. Socrates and his companions submit inherited beliefs to the discipline of questioning; Genesis begins with a God whose word brings the world into being. One tradition has come to stand for what human reason can discover, the other for what must first be received. Yet Socrates begins his evening at a religious festival, and the Scriptures will give us men who argue with God, demand justice, and refuse easy answers. The two cities are not as different as their emblems suggest, nor are their differences easily dissolved. We begin with an unanswered question in Athens and an astonishing declaration in Jerusalem: Socrates cannot yet say what justice is, while Genesis has already said what man is. Whether we can know what we ought to do without first knowing what we are—and whether we can know what we are without asking what we ought to do—is a question that will occupy us for a long time.

04. Questions

Reflection Questions

Optional reflection prompts

Saved
1

Socrates argues that harming a horse makes it worse as a horse, and that harming a person makes him worse in human excellence, which Polemarchus agrees is justice. Return to the argument and consider whether injury must have that effect. Think of a wrong you have suffered or committed. Did it make anyone less just, or might suffering a wrong sometimes make someone better?

2

God gives human beings dominion over the creatures and the earth, but names no other human being in the grant. In the second account, the man is given a garden to cultivate and keep, and a woman comparable to him. What distinguishes caring for something entrusted to you from claiming ownership or mastery over another person? Where in your own life do you exercise authority, and what gives you the right to exercise it?

3

Polemarchus is willing to harm the wicked enemy, but Socrates argues that a just person may harm no one. Genesis gives God's image to human beings before they have done anything to deserve or forfeit another person's favor. Think of someone who has genuinely wronged you. If you ought not harm that person, is the stronger reason found in the kind of person you must be, or in the kind of being that person already is?

Live Tutor

Interactive dialogue about the texts.

Paideia Tutor

We just learned that Socrates brought Polemarchus, whom the Thirty would later execute without trial, to agree that a just person harms no one, not even a wicked enemy, while Genesis gave the image of God, a dignity associated with kings in the ancient Near East, to man, male and female. What aspect of this lesson would you like to discuss?